Architects honor grand designs, Kansas City Star, by Steve Paul, Nov. 19, 2010

 

A Greensburg, Kan., school, a small commercial building in Waldo and the Kansas City Convention Center's Grand Ballroom have been named standout design projects of the year by the local American Institute of Architects chapter.

Honor awards, chosen unanimously by a panel of outside architects, went Friday night to these three projects, all predominantly modern in style:

Botwin Building

Botwin Family Partners' commercial building in Waldo includes a drawing by artist Anne Lindberg in the second-story glazing, which helps reduce heat.

•A new K-12 campus, designed by BNIM, in the tornado-flattened and now-rebuilding town of Greensburg.

•A two-level, glass-walled modernist building, with a planted roof, at 75th and Washington streets, designed by El Dorado Inc. The building, dubbed "Replanted," replaced the old Waldo Theater, which was destroyed by fire in 2007.

•The $70 million city ballroom, by HNTB Architecture. Judges saw the Convention Center addition as a well-executed civic space, an accomplishment rarely achieved in such projects. They especially liked how its simple, modern design reflected the classical lineage of architecture.

The jury included Marlon Blackwell, an architect and teacher in Fayetteville, Ark.; Charles Linn, a Topeka native and longtime writer for Architectural Record; and Kirsten Ring Murray, a Seattle architect. They considered 81 entries.

The work of BNIM dominated the jury's attention. Of 12 awards given out in three tiers of recognition, BNIM won four and shared in a fifth. Another big winner, El Dorado, won awards in each category. The middle-tier merit awards went to El Dorado for its Unitarian Fellowship chapel, outside Lawrence; to Gould Evans for its South Junior High School, also in Lawrence; to a team of BNIM and 360 Architecture for J.E. Dunn's new headquarters in downtown Kansas City; and to BNIM for the City Union Mission's Christian Life Center, the Blue Valley School District's Support Services Center and the Omega Center for Sustainable Living in Rhinebeck, N.Y.

The Omega Center, a wastewater treatment facility that has gotten nationwide attention for advancing the principles of sustainable building, prompted the most heated debate in the judging. Although admired for addressing the stringent requirements of a "living building" — producing all its own energy, for example — BNIM’s design left judges divided over its qualities as architecture.

This was architecture's greatest challenge, the jury members agreed, to find a satisfying balance between the purely functional and inspired design.

Third-tier citation awards were given to Helix for its renovation of the AIA chapter's new headquarters, 1801 McGee St.; to Gould Evans for the design of an unbuilt high school expansion in Manhattan, Kan.; and to El Dorado for the Finn Lofts, a warehouse conversion in Wichita.